The National Fragile X Foundation and our members are closely tied to autism: FXS—one of the more than 800 genes associated with autism—is the most common known single gene cause of autism, accounting for 1%–6% of all cases. Additionally, 46% of males and 16% of females with FXS have been diagnosed or treated for autism.
Here we take a look at behavioral issues in individuals with FXS plus ASD and compare them to those with FXS alone.
Studies involving the impact of an ASD co-diagnosis in FXS have to date relied mostly on parent-reported data and/or smaller sample populations. But thanks to the registry and longitudinal database FORWARD—the Fragile X Online Registry With Accessible Research Database—plus standardized clinician- and parent-reported data from 25 Fragile X clinics, we now have access to samples large enough to include a breakdown of findings by age groups.
What is the FORWARD Registry & Database?
In order to conduct well-designed clinical trials that capture the entire spectrum of the disorder, the natural history of those with Fragile X syndrome needs to be determined. This is particularly true for adults with FXS, about whom almost nothing is known regarding life trajectory and medical complications. Supported by grants from the CDC, the FORWARD Registry & Database (a project of the NFXF Fragile X Clinical & Research Consortium) was created to increase the scientific and clinical understanding of Fragile X syndrome.
The Impact of an ASD Co-Diagnosis on Behaviors in FXS
There are many different types of behaviors associated with ASD, regardless of ASD status and age, particularly attention issues and anxiety. In the first large scale study looking at autism in FXS, and using FORWARD and Fragile X clinic data, the charts below shows behaviors associated with FXS+ASD and FXS only, by age group (ages 3–11 and 12–21), in subjects enrolled in theFORWARD Database from September 7, 2012, through August 31, 2014.
In general, the behavioral profiles were similar in both age groups. Regardless of their relative frequency, however, hyperactivity, hypersensitivity/overreactivity, perseverative/obsessive compulsive behavior, and irritability/aggressive behavior was much higher among those with FXS+ASD versus those with FXS only. The difference between FXS+ASD and FXS was less striking for anxiety, with only the older (ages 12–21) FXS+ASD group showing significantly higher anxiety than FXS only (98% vs. 87%). As a whole, mood swings/depression problems were less common (∼18%), with no significant difference between FXS+ASD and FXS only.
Behavioral problems associated with FXS+ASD and FXS only, by age group, in subjects enrolled from September 7, 2012 through August 31, 2014, FORWARD Database.
Other findings from the study included:
- FXS+ASD individuals were about 3x more likely to experience seizures.
- Sleep problems requiring treatment were found in 4 out of 10 with FXS+ASD vs. 3 out of 10 for FXS alone.
- Aggressive/disruptive behavior was treated with medication in 4 out of 10 of individuals with FXS+ASD vs. 2 out of 10 for those with FXS alone. Other behaviors were treated similarly in both groups.
Separately, FXS and ASD share many overlapping issues, so it’s important to understand these differences to ensure an accurate diagnosis. Most FXS behavioral issues trace back to anxiety and hyperarousal. Autism’s behavioral roots and manifestations are more complex and multi-faceted, which makes it essential to understand the root of the behavior before committing to a treatment plan.
And while parents may be well aware of the differences between FXS, ASD, and FXS+ASD, teachers, clinicians, and other professionals, need to understand that FXS+ASD isn’t merely a sum of its parts. But if FXS is just one cause out of an unknown number for autism, how does one affect the other? Unfortunately, we don’t yet know the answer to this question.
Learn More About Autism
To learn more about autism, here are some video resources to get you started:
Ted Talks are great for learning about, well, most anything! Check out Ted Talks related to autism, or skip straight to the most popular talks:
We have been busy putting more information about Fragile X and autism together as a resource here at fragilex.org, and have been compiling facts, information, articles, webinars, information on studies and research, and will continue to add more as they become available. It is ever changing, but in the meantime, check out Fragile X & Autism.
And watch for more information throughout the month of April, here and on social media. And if you haven’t already, don’t forget to subscribe so you don’t miss anything.
The Fragile X Syndrome–Autism Comorbidity: What Do We Really Know? »
This study looks at important differences in ASD symptoms between individuals with FXS+ASD and those with ASD alone.
Q&A With Dr. Hagerman: Exploring the Fragile X Syndrome / Autism Link »
Fragile X expert Dr. Hagerman discusses the important link between FXS and autism, and new developments and treatments for both.
Clinical Insights into the Similarities and Differences for Diagnosis and Treatment »
The two conditions may have considerably more overlap than previously thought.
FXCRC Consensus Document “Autism Spectrum Disorder in Fragile X Syndrome” »
Recommendations based on the information collected from all the families who participate in FORWARD and other scientific research.
The Fragile X Family of Disorders: A Model for Autism and Targeted Treatments »
By Randi J. Hagerman, Susan M. Rivera, and Paul J. Hagerman.